This is a response to a theatre review by Ben Brantley
'Marriage as Blood Sport: A No-Win Game'
March 21, 2005
http://theater2.nytimes.com/2005/03/21/theater/reviews/21wool.html
He got it right: most Americans would agree that marriage is a blood-sport where everyone ultimately loses. In his review, Ben Brantley gives a congratulatory applause to Anthony Page’s production of ‘Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf’ by saying that this ‘welcome surprise’ will make the audience leaving the theater ‘feeling like winners.’ Brantley gives a detailed analysis of the actors and their interpretation of the characters in the play, however, for readers with no previous experiences with Uta Hagen, Arthur Hill, Elizabeth Taylor, Richard Burton, or the play itself for that matter are left clueless by the comment like ‘there probably has never been a "Virginia Woolf" in which the leading roles initially register as such elemental contrasts.”
Brantley continues commending the success of the production by commenting on Director Page’s interpretation by which he tempered the original play's notorious vitriol with eye-opening compassion. According to Brantley, the actors - under Page and through their exceptional acting - restore characters who have acquired the faces of Freudian monsters to purely.
His review seems to be geared toward the older – perhaps middle aged – metropolitan theatergoer couples who had already been there, done that (marriage that is!) However, his raving claim about the ‘satisfaction that comes from witnessing one helluva fight’ is enough to draw in younger audience as well.
Wednesday, February 13, 2008
Monday, February 11, 2008
Now, Tell Me How You Feel..
Review - In Treatment
Each year, about 4 percent of the Americans are said to be ‘in treatment.’ America is the homeland for (psycho)therapies and it is deeply ingrained in American culture. Either you have ever been in therapy, known someone in therapy, or just really like the star-studded cast featuring Gabriel Byrne and Dianne Wiest, "In Treatment" gives an interesting insights on psychotherapies.
Adapted from a popular Israeli TV show titled Be ‘Tipul, In Treatment follows Paul Weston, a psychotherapist played by Gabriel Byrne. Each night of the week, Paul keeps regular appointments with the same patients, except for Fridays, when he goes to see Dr. Gina Toll played by Dianne Wiest. The half-hour drama involves more talking than one might expect from a real therapy. Patients stand up and wander around the room a bit, as if they were not so much of patients seeking help, but as actors reciting monologues for an audition. The dialogue does not leave a lasting impression. At times the setting where a couple people are sitting in a room talking for half an hour becomes too stagey, and potentially boring. Also the level of antagonism each patient brings to Dr.Weston not only strains the credibility of the show but also the dramatic pitch.
In attempt to add some excitement, In Treatment offers occasional spurts of in-session violence or some intense confessions. Laura, played by Melissa George, chokes up talking about how she had dreamt of Weston confessing his undying love for her and beginning their future together. The lurid confession of Laura is grating and perverted rather than being seductive to the extent that makes the viewer wiggle uncomfortably in their seats.
Going back to the issue of believability, if Weston were a real psychologist, he would be in a great danger of losing his license because he speaks in over-sentimental terms, which could be viewed as malpractice. Part of this can be blamed on the character who is truly devoted to his clients yet is depressed, egotistical and whiny. Byrne does on exceptional job at utilizing his bushy eyebrows and the droopy eyes to their best advantage, making Paul a man seeking for an answer to his failings even if he cannot quite admit it.
Oscar award winning actress, Diane Wiest, with relatively few lines, radiates the wisdom and bewilderment of a retired woman. With her easy laugh and mercilessly direct questions, she, once again, becomes a therapist and a mentor whom Weston broke with years ago. Her accent, the China-collared shirt, tranquil voice, and insightful lines like ‘there’s a sadness in your voice when you talk about Kate,’ she resembles a Buddhist monk or Mother Nature.
Even with the interesting concept and some exceptional performance by Byrne and Wiest, the inconsistent level of acting of different characters makes the show seem like an amateur theatrical experiment. Once again, the session ends, but whether it was worth the time and the money invested – by both viewers and the producers – remains questionable.
Each year, about 4 percent of the Americans are said to be ‘in treatment.’ America is the homeland for (psycho)therapies and it is deeply ingrained in American culture. Either you have ever been in therapy, known someone in therapy, or just really like the star-studded cast featuring Gabriel Byrne and Dianne Wiest, "In Treatment" gives an interesting insights on psychotherapies.
Adapted from a popular Israeli TV show titled Be ‘Tipul, In Treatment follows Paul Weston, a psychotherapist played by Gabriel Byrne. Each night of the week, Paul keeps regular appointments with the same patients, except for Fridays, when he goes to see Dr. Gina Toll played by Dianne Wiest. The half-hour drama involves more talking than one might expect from a real therapy. Patients stand up and wander around the room a bit, as if they were not so much of patients seeking help, but as actors reciting monologues for an audition. The dialogue does not leave a lasting impression. At times the setting where a couple people are sitting in a room talking for half an hour becomes too stagey, and potentially boring. Also the level of antagonism each patient brings to Dr.Weston not only strains the credibility of the show but also the dramatic pitch.
In attempt to add some excitement, In Treatment offers occasional spurts of in-session violence or some intense confessions. Laura, played by Melissa George, chokes up talking about how she had dreamt of Weston confessing his undying love for her and beginning their future together. The lurid confession of Laura is grating and perverted rather than being seductive to the extent that makes the viewer wiggle uncomfortably in their seats.
Going back to the issue of believability, if Weston were a real psychologist, he would be in a great danger of losing his license because he speaks in over-sentimental terms, which could be viewed as malpractice. Part of this can be blamed on the character who is truly devoted to his clients yet is depressed, egotistical and whiny. Byrne does on exceptional job at utilizing his bushy eyebrows and the droopy eyes to their best advantage, making Paul a man seeking for an answer to his failings even if he cannot quite admit it.
Oscar award winning actress, Diane Wiest, with relatively few lines, radiates the wisdom and bewilderment of a retired woman. With her easy laugh and mercilessly direct questions, she, once again, becomes a therapist and a mentor whom Weston broke with years ago. Her accent, the China-collared shirt, tranquil voice, and insightful lines like ‘there’s a sadness in your voice when you talk about Kate,’ she resembles a Buddhist monk or Mother Nature.
Even with the interesting concept and some exceptional performance by Byrne and Wiest, the inconsistent level of acting of different characters makes the show seem like an amateur theatrical experiment. Once again, the session ends, but whether it was worth the time and the money invested – by both viewers and the producers – remains questionable.
Wednesday, February 6, 2008
Response to Oscar Wilde
So, here comes the big question that has been long debated: What is a critic? What does a critic do? The simplest and the most straightforward answer would be a person who offers reasoned judgment or analysis, interpretation, or observation. But is he also an artist? What is criticism outside creation?
Oscar Wilde, an Irish writer with languishing attitude who often appears in cartoons wearing a ‘too-too’ skirt, takes a serious stab at what it means to be a critic in the Critic as Artist. Known for his involvement in aesthetic movement, Wilde argued that the art should provide refined sensuous pleasure, rather than convey moral or philosophical messages. According to him, the art, since it has no didactic purpose, needs only to be beautiful. In the self-righteous voice of Gilbert, Wilde, insists that art is always the result of the most self-conscious effort.
It seems fair to say that great artists worked unconsciously and that they were wiser than they knew as Emerson once said. Then are we, as critics, all looking for something that is not there? Trying to find – or give - meanings in nothing? Gilbert says that the age that has no criticism is either an age in which art is immobile, hieratic, and confined to the reproduction of formal types, or an age that possesses no art at all. If that statement were to be true, how about people taking a pre-historical artifact and consider it to be a beautiful piece of art? It seems paradoxical: by lending to other ages – such as pre historical era when there was no form of criticism, thus no art – what we think we desire for our own – beauty – we are ‘creating’ art. If art means being beautiful, and if one can find meaning in something, just about anything and everything can be called art. So is it really that the primary aim of the critic is to see the object as in itself it really is not?
If Wilde [in the voice of Gilbert] is right, how can criticism be an art? Didn’t he say that art has no purpose or meaning other than being beautiful? Having some sort of a profound meaning as it possesses no meaning at all… He starts to sound more like a philosopher than anything. Perhaps it is more correct to say that the criticism completes art, or that the criticism gives meaning to art.
Gilbert tells Ernest that criticism demands infinitely more cultivation than creation does. To know the vintage and quality of a wine one need not drink the whole cask. Ten minutes must be perfectly sufficient to say whether a book is worth anything or worth nothing, if one has the instinct form. Going with Wilde’s wine metaphor, then, a well-educated sommelier always right? Some research shows that all these sommeliers failed blind testing. Many reviews on wine are inflated. Our senses are all messed up by its label. This reminded me of a story from Afterglow where critics across the nation gave a movie raving reviews because they thought Pauline Kael did so, when in fact she hadn’t even seen the movie. Conscious aim at art is a delusion in a sense. A critic will be always showing us the work of art in some new relation to our age.
But is such work as Gilbert has talked about really criticism? It criticizes not merely the individual work of art, but Beauty in self. Why should people care? (Gilbert, at one point, asks Who cares whether Mr. Ruskin’s views on Turner are sound or not? What does it matter? But really, why do we care what anyone says if art only has personal meanings?)
When Gilbert’s long lecture on what it means to be a critic was finally over, a quote from the movie Thank You for Smoking came to my mind: “if you argue right, you are always right.” As Springfield Republican once commented on Wilde’s behavior, his conduct seems more of a bid for notoriety or a controversy than a devotion to beauty and the aesthetic.
As he began to be involved in the aesthetic movement, Oscar Wilde began wearing his hair long and began decorating his rooms with peacock feathers, lilies, sunflowers, blue china and other objets d'art. It makes me wonder what self-conscious effort Wilde had to make to justify the beauty in a peacock feather. At least, to my uncultivated eyes, a peacock feather is just a colorful bird feather.
Oscar Wilde, an Irish writer with languishing attitude who often appears in cartoons wearing a ‘too-too’ skirt, takes a serious stab at what it means to be a critic in the Critic as Artist. Known for his involvement in aesthetic movement, Wilde argued that the art should provide refined sensuous pleasure, rather than convey moral or philosophical messages. According to him, the art, since it has no didactic purpose, needs only to be beautiful. In the self-righteous voice of Gilbert, Wilde, insists that art is always the result of the most self-conscious effort.
It seems fair to say that great artists worked unconsciously and that they were wiser than they knew as Emerson once said. Then are we, as critics, all looking for something that is not there? Trying to find – or give - meanings in nothing? Gilbert says that the age that has no criticism is either an age in which art is immobile, hieratic, and confined to the reproduction of formal types, or an age that possesses no art at all. If that statement were to be true, how about people taking a pre-historical artifact and consider it to be a beautiful piece of art? It seems paradoxical: by lending to other ages – such as pre historical era when there was no form of criticism, thus no art – what we think we desire for our own – beauty – we are ‘creating’ art. If art means being beautiful, and if one can find meaning in something, just about anything and everything can be called art. So is it really that the primary aim of the critic is to see the object as in itself it really is not?
If Wilde [in the voice of Gilbert] is right, how can criticism be an art? Didn’t he say that art has no purpose or meaning other than being beautiful? Having some sort of a profound meaning as it possesses no meaning at all… He starts to sound more like a philosopher than anything. Perhaps it is more correct to say that the criticism completes art, or that the criticism gives meaning to art.
Gilbert tells Ernest that criticism demands infinitely more cultivation than creation does. To know the vintage and quality of a wine one need not drink the whole cask. Ten minutes must be perfectly sufficient to say whether a book is worth anything or worth nothing, if one has the instinct form. Going with Wilde’s wine metaphor, then, a well-educated sommelier always right? Some research shows that all these sommeliers failed blind testing. Many reviews on wine are inflated. Our senses are all messed up by its label. This reminded me of a story from Afterglow where critics across the nation gave a movie raving reviews because they thought Pauline Kael did so, when in fact she hadn’t even seen the movie. Conscious aim at art is a delusion in a sense. A critic will be always showing us the work of art in some new relation to our age.
But is such work as Gilbert has talked about really criticism? It criticizes not merely the individual work of art, but Beauty in self. Why should people care? (Gilbert, at one point, asks Who cares whether Mr. Ruskin’s views on Turner are sound or not? What does it matter? But really, why do we care what anyone says if art only has personal meanings?)
When Gilbert’s long lecture on what it means to be a critic was finally over, a quote from the movie Thank You for Smoking came to my mind: “if you argue right, you are always right.” As Springfield Republican once commented on Wilde’s behavior, his conduct seems more of a bid for notoriety or a controversy than a devotion to beauty and the aesthetic.
As he began to be involved in the aesthetic movement, Oscar Wilde began wearing his hair long and began decorating his rooms with peacock feathers, lilies, sunflowers, blue china and other objets d'art. It makes me wonder what self-conscious effort Wilde had to make to justify the beauty in a peacock feather. At least, to my uncultivated eyes, a peacock feather is just a colorful bird feather.
Monday, February 4, 2008
Response to Pauline Kael
Since the 1940s, according to Renata Adler, the New York Times has reviewed almost every movie that opened in New York as it would not consider reviewing every book, exhibit, or cultural event. Movie is one of many favorite pastimes of American people and it brings up broad critical discussions. In that sense, Pauline Kael had a significant impact on the 20th Century’s culture industry.
In a delightful memento of whom often addressed as the most influential film critic of our time, Afterglow, Kael’s acerbic, yet honest insights on a variety of topics come through in an informal interview clearly and entertainingly as they did in her published reviews. Francis Davis, author and a friend of Kael, confesses how he once used Kael’s review to convince a friend to watch a movie with him. Her enthusiasm for films is highly contagious for she praised or slammed the movie with frivolous vitality. The colorful details and vivid images she presents to the readers are stimulating. However, upon deciding that she does not appreciate the movie, her bitter straight-shooting is enough to make one wonder if Kael has any sympathy for the movie director or the actors.
Pauline Kael always wrote with brutal honesty and that is what makes her stand out. She is not afraid to write as she saw things. In the times when the critics are way too concerned with having the ‘right taste,’ Kael’s confident voice is very refreshing. One may have a total opposite taste in film as Kael, yet cannot help but to feel curious what she has to say about the new film. The honesty and sincerity under all her flare allows her readers to relate – or empathize – better with her reviews.
Another great merit of hers was that she wanted to write about movies the way people really talked as they were leaving the theatre. She believed that writing in academic English in an attempt to elevate movies actually lowers them. She was a professional movie critic, and of course her reviews are a little more elaborate than simply saying ‘good, bad, or ugly.’ However, Kael’s reviews are not at all intimidating – you do not have to read the same sentence over and over again to figure out what it means.
Pauline Kael bluntly complains how we all have become a heavy-handed society that wants movies to be about the misery and alienation of our generation. However, her claim of being a fan of lighthearted lowbrow movies is jeopardized by Adler’s critic that she, in principle, likes frissons of horror; physical violence; sex scenes; and fantasies of invasion in films (and most people would agree that those are heavy and turgid topics.) Her reviews also indicate her fondness of heated up discussions and conflicts.
Although, often accused of writing more stimulating reviews than the actual film, and also of writing about everything else – including the related social issues – but the fil itself, her reviews easily provoke curiosity in any reader. Either convinced by her rave, or just to see if she’s right, or even for the sake of proving one of the most influential critics of the time wrong, Kael’s readers once again head to the box office.
In a delightful memento of whom often addressed as the most influential film critic of our time, Afterglow, Kael’s acerbic, yet honest insights on a variety of topics come through in an informal interview clearly and entertainingly as they did in her published reviews. Francis Davis, author and a friend of Kael, confesses how he once used Kael’s review to convince a friend to watch a movie with him. Her enthusiasm for films is highly contagious for she praised or slammed the movie with frivolous vitality. The colorful details and vivid images she presents to the readers are stimulating. However, upon deciding that she does not appreciate the movie, her bitter straight-shooting is enough to make one wonder if Kael has any sympathy for the movie director or the actors.
Pauline Kael always wrote with brutal honesty and that is what makes her stand out. She is not afraid to write as she saw things. In the times when the critics are way too concerned with having the ‘right taste,’ Kael’s confident voice is very refreshing. One may have a total opposite taste in film as Kael, yet cannot help but to feel curious what she has to say about the new film. The honesty and sincerity under all her flare allows her readers to relate – or empathize – better with her reviews.
Another great merit of hers was that she wanted to write about movies the way people really talked as they were leaving the theatre. She believed that writing in academic English in an attempt to elevate movies actually lowers them. She was a professional movie critic, and of course her reviews are a little more elaborate than simply saying ‘good, bad, or ugly.’ However, Kael’s reviews are not at all intimidating – you do not have to read the same sentence over and over again to figure out what it means.
Pauline Kael bluntly complains how we all have become a heavy-handed society that wants movies to be about the misery and alienation of our generation. However, her claim of being a fan of lighthearted lowbrow movies is jeopardized by Adler’s critic that she, in principle, likes frissons of horror; physical violence; sex scenes; and fantasies of invasion in films (and most people would agree that those are heavy and turgid topics.) Her reviews also indicate her fondness of heated up discussions and conflicts.
Although, often accused of writing more stimulating reviews than the actual film, and also of writing about everything else – including the related social issues – but the fil itself, her reviews easily provoke curiosity in any reader. Either convinced by her rave, or just to see if she’s right, or even for the sake of proving one of the most influential critics of the time wrong, Kael’s readers once again head to the box office.
Tuesday, January 29, 2008
Response to Afterflow by Francis Davis
In this delightful little memento of Pauline Kael, who is often addressed as the most influential film critic of our time, her acerbic, yet honest insights on a variety of topics come through in this informal interview clearly and entertainingly as they did in her published reviews. Kael is infamous for writing with brutal honesty on movies, directors and actors. Although, it was not her intention, she did not care who she offended or upset, but called them as she saw them.
As the author, Francis Davis confesses how he once used Kael’s review to convince a friend to watch a movie with him, Kael’s enthusiasm for films is highly contagious for she praised or slammed the movie with frivolous vitality.
The honesty and sincerity under all her flare allows her readers to relate better with her reviews. Being introduced to this legendary critic for the first time, I almost fell in love with her when Kael said, "It's not fun writing about bad movies. I used to think it was bad for my skin." She also wanted to write about movies the way people really talked as they were leaving the theatre. She believed that – and I strongly agree to this point – writing in academic English in an attempt to elevate movies actually lowers them. She quotes, “It denied them what makes them distinctive.”
A fan of classic dancer-comedians like the Ritz Brothers, Pauline Kael, bluntly complains how we all have become a heavy-handed society that wants movies to be about the misery and alienation of our generation. I often wonder, especially in a class like Arts Journalism, if watching – and enjoying – light movies makes me appear less intelligent. People, especially in academic settings like Kalamazoo College, seem to expect a movie to be heavy, turgid and moral, as Pauline puts it.
The slim 126-page book devoted to a real conversation between two friends is more a highlight of her legacy than anything. Definitely interesting and enjoyable, yet, Afterglow has the feel of a finale of a reality TV show.
As the author, Francis Davis confesses how he once used Kael’s review to convince a friend to watch a movie with him, Kael’s enthusiasm for films is highly contagious for she praised or slammed the movie with frivolous vitality.
The honesty and sincerity under all her flare allows her readers to relate better with her reviews. Being introduced to this legendary critic for the first time, I almost fell in love with her when Kael said, "It's not fun writing about bad movies. I used to think it was bad for my skin." She also wanted to write about movies the way people really talked as they were leaving the theatre. She believed that – and I strongly agree to this point – writing in academic English in an attempt to elevate movies actually lowers them. She quotes, “It denied them what makes them distinctive.”
A fan of classic dancer-comedians like the Ritz Brothers, Pauline Kael, bluntly complains how we all have become a heavy-handed society that wants movies to be about the misery and alienation of our generation. I often wonder, especially in a class like Arts Journalism, if watching – and enjoying – light movies makes me appear less intelligent. People, especially in academic settings like Kalamazoo College, seem to expect a movie to be heavy, turgid and moral, as Pauline puts it.
The slim 126-page book devoted to a real conversation between two friends is more a highlight of her legacy than anything. Definitely interesting and enjoyable, yet, Afterglow has the feel of a finale of a reality TV show.
Monday, January 28, 2008
Once Review
Falling Slowly, Once Again
There is a guy who is living a life of a pathetic Dublin busker – or a self-claimed ‘broken hearted hoover fixer sucker guy’ - after a breakup, and a girl who is living a life of an immigrant mother with a young daughter she had as a result of her ‘hanky panky.’ As the piano accompanies the guitar solo, she starts to sing in harmony to the song he used to sing alone, and slowly the song that began as a pleading monologue turns into a rich conversation. The Irish musical film, Once, written and directed by John Carney, shows how beautiful our routined life can be without adding too many accidentals to the piece.
The movie poster asks, ‘how often do you find the right person?’ It is hard to say, but Glen Hansard. 37, and Marketa Irglova, 19, a real life couple, definitely had found each other. Both professional musicians with limited acting experiences, Hansard and Irglova appear awkward and flat in the film, however, Carney allows them to adapt this major flaw into their personalities on screen, and also as the authenticity of the film. Casting ‘good singers who could half act,’ as Carney said in a Chicago interview, was an essential choice. The music really is the centerpiece of the film, and the way the emotion of the character blends with the songs to create a unified story is genuine and sincere.
The two main characters remain nameless throughout the movie. Credited as Guy and Girl, they understand each other through music, thus asking questions or giving answers seems unnecessary. Likewise, the audiences are able to empathize with the characters without knowing their names nor being assured that their relationship inclines love. When Guy finally decides to ask Girl if she still loves her husband, she answers him back in Czech, coyly refusing to tell Guy what it means – you may choose to find out what it means online, but some things are better left unknown!
This $160,000 low-budget movie filmed with a long lens camera even had an apologetic warning sign in Korean theatres before the showing, regarding its poor screen condition. However, the unsteady, home video like camera angle is what makes the movie seem much more real. In the beginning scene, the camera bobs along as it draws closer to the singing Guy. For a moment there, it is as if we are seeing Grafton, Dublin’s famous shopping district, through Girl’s eyes, not through a camera lens. This honest quality brings the viewers right to the heart of Dublin.
The movie that starts out with a lonely street performer makes a smooth transition to the scene where Guy, Girl, their band, friends and families are all gathered together around the dinner table, showing the creation of relationships in parallel to that of music.
Carney does a great job quilting the little pieces of the ordinary lives with mesmerizing melodies, capturing the moment of two talented musicians with burdened shoulders ‘falling slowly’ for each other.
There is a guy who is living a life of a pathetic Dublin busker – or a self-claimed ‘broken hearted hoover fixer sucker guy’ - after a breakup, and a girl who is living a life of an immigrant mother with a young daughter she had as a result of her ‘hanky panky.’ As the piano accompanies the guitar solo, she starts to sing in harmony to the song he used to sing alone, and slowly the song that began as a pleading monologue turns into a rich conversation. The Irish musical film, Once, written and directed by John Carney, shows how beautiful our routined life can be without adding too many accidentals to the piece.
The movie poster asks, ‘how often do you find the right person?’ It is hard to say, but Glen Hansard. 37, and Marketa Irglova, 19, a real life couple, definitely had found each other. Both professional musicians with limited acting experiences, Hansard and Irglova appear awkward and flat in the film, however, Carney allows them to adapt this major flaw into their personalities on screen, and also as the authenticity of the film. Casting ‘good singers who could half act,’ as Carney said in a Chicago interview, was an essential choice. The music really is the centerpiece of the film, and the way the emotion of the character blends with the songs to create a unified story is genuine and sincere.
The two main characters remain nameless throughout the movie. Credited as Guy and Girl, they understand each other through music, thus asking questions or giving answers seems unnecessary. Likewise, the audiences are able to empathize with the characters without knowing their names nor being assured that their relationship inclines love. When Guy finally decides to ask Girl if she still loves her husband, she answers him back in Czech, coyly refusing to tell Guy what it means – you may choose to find out what it means online, but some things are better left unknown!
This $160,000 low-budget movie filmed with a long lens camera even had an apologetic warning sign in Korean theatres before the showing, regarding its poor screen condition. However, the unsteady, home video like camera angle is what makes the movie seem much more real. In the beginning scene, the camera bobs along as it draws closer to the singing Guy. For a moment there, it is as if we are seeing Grafton, Dublin’s famous shopping district, through Girl’s eyes, not through a camera lens. This honest quality brings the viewers right to the heart of Dublin.
The movie that starts out with a lonely street performer makes a smooth transition to the scene where Guy, Girl, their band, friends and families are all gathered together around the dinner table, showing the creation of relationships in parallel to that of music.
Carney does a great job quilting the little pieces of the ordinary lives with mesmerizing melodies, capturing the moment of two talented musicians with burdened shoulders ‘falling slowly’ for each other.
Wednesday, January 23, 2008
Writers Strike Response – Drum Roll Please, and the 2008 Oscar goes to…
So, the Writers Strike has resulted in an 1.5 billion dollar loss in Los Angeles area alone, and even more money is at stake with no clear answer to whether the show, specifically the Oscar, will still go on.
At the heart of this long lasted feud are three major issues: DVD residuals; union jurisdiction over animation and reality program writers; and compensation for "new media"—content written for the Internet. In more simple terms, ‘who gets the money?’ issue. With the nation’s most prominent writers like John Wells at the front of the picket line, I personally cannot be any less sympathetic for two reasons; they must have millions and millions of dollars already, do they really need more dough? Plus, I don’t even watch TV anymore!
Surprisingly, I am not alone. According to the SurveyUSA poll result, the 75% of respondents were found to have little to no concern over the strike, and the USA TODAY poll shows that 49% of the viewers said they were more likely to watch reruns, 40% said they planned to watch reality series and other programming not disrupted by the strike, and 26% were more likely to buy or rent DVDs of television series from past seasons. These not-so-empathetic poll results almost makes me wonder, ‘is the era when the Sunday paper’s TV guide was the new American Bible finally coming to an end?
Of course, the writers must fight for their rights, and of course, they should be compensated fairly for all their hard work which requires a lot of hair-pulling, energy drinks, and no sleep. But, is this really working? Will the 11 weeks of struggle be in vain? It is definitely a close competition between the Writers and the Producers, and the winner is soon to be announced. Now drum roll, please, and the 2008 Oscar goes to…
Related Links:
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/01/23/business/media/23strike.html?_r=1&scp=1&sq=writers++guild&st=nyt&oref=slogin
http://www.usatoday.com/life/television/news/2007-12-18-strike-poll_N.htm
http://www.surveyusa.com/client/PollReportEmail.aspx?g=bbb91c3a-2bf2-4ef4-a009-e588fef04ed2
At the heart of this long lasted feud are three major issues: DVD residuals; union jurisdiction over animation and reality program writers; and compensation for "new media"—content written for the Internet. In more simple terms, ‘who gets the money?’ issue. With the nation’s most prominent writers like John Wells at the front of the picket line, I personally cannot be any less sympathetic for two reasons; they must have millions and millions of dollars already, do they really need more dough? Plus, I don’t even watch TV anymore!
Surprisingly, I am not alone. According to the SurveyUSA poll result, the 75% of respondents were found to have little to no concern over the strike, and the USA TODAY poll shows that 49% of the viewers said they were more likely to watch reruns, 40% said they planned to watch reality series and other programming not disrupted by the strike, and 26% were more likely to buy or rent DVDs of television series from past seasons. These not-so-empathetic poll results almost makes me wonder, ‘is the era when the Sunday paper’s TV guide was the new American Bible finally coming to an end?
Of course, the writers must fight for their rights, and of course, they should be compensated fairly for all their hard work which requires a lot of hair-pulling, energy drinks, and no sleep. But, is this really working? Will the 11 weeks of struggle be in vain? It is definitely a close competition between the Writers and the Producers, and the winner is soon to be announced. Now drum roll, please, and the 2008 Oscar goes to…
Related Links:
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/01/23/business/media/23strike.html?_r=1&scp=1&sq=writers++guild&st=nyt&oref=slogin
http://www.usatoday.com/life/television/news/2007-12-18-strike-poll_N.htm
http://www.surveyusa.com/client/PollReportEmail.aspx?g=bbb91c3a-2bf2-4ef4-a009-e588fef04ed2
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)